top of page
Search

Whitening Your Teeth? Read This First

Whether you’re posing for family photos, heading to a work event, or meeting friends out and about in Buffalo, a confident smile always helps. In fact, “How do I whiten my teeth safely?” is one of the most common cosmetic questions I get.


So before you pick up the first whitening kit you see online, here’s what actually works, what to skip, and how to protect your enamel along the way.


First Things First: Know Your Stains


Extrinsic stains, surface

  • Form on the outer layer of enamel

  • Common culprits include coffee, tea, red wine, dark sauces, and tobacco

  • Usually respond well to polishing or peroxide-based whitening


Intrinsic stains, internal

  • Sit deeper in the dentin

  • Causes include certain medications, dental trauma, aging, and previous dental procedures

  • Often need professional-grade whitening, or restorative options like veneers or crowns, for noticeable improvement


Why this matters: if your discoloration is mostly extrinsic, over the counter products may help. Intrinsic stains usually benefit from a stronger, dentist supervised plan.


Option 1: In Office Whitening, Fast and Supervised


When you want predictable results quickly, professional whitening under a dentist’s care is hard to beat. Here’s why:


  1. Gum protection. We isolate gums and lips so only enamel sees the peroxide.

  2. High strength gel. Often 35% to 40% hydrogen peroxide, several times stronger than most strips.

  3. Optional light activation. LED or laser systems can speed things along.

  4. Rinse and reveal. Many patients see 6 to 8 shades of improvement in about an hour.


Pros: Fast, controlled, immediate results.Cons: Higher upfront cost, still need smart habits to maintain results, likely post-op sensitivity


Option 2: Custom Take Home Trays, Dentist Guided DIY


If you prefer to whiten gradually on your own schedule, custom trays are my go to recommendation:


  • We take impressions or a digital scan and create trays that fit precisely

  • You use a professional gel, often 10% to 15% carbamide peroxide, for 30 to 60 minutes per day over 10 to 14 days

  • Occasional touch ups every few months keep things bright


Why I like them: Even coverage, fewer strip lines, and less gum irritation than store bought strips. For most patients, this hits the sweet spot for convenience, safety, and value.


Option 3: Store Bought Products, Helpful with Limits


Whitening strips

  • Usually 5% to 10% hydrogen peroxide on a flexible strip

  • Can lighten 1 to 2 shades after daily use for two to four weeks

  • Coverage can be uneven on rotated or crowded teeth


Paint on pens

  • Similar strength to strips

  • Handy for quick touch ups, but saliva can dilute the gel quickly


Whitening toothpaste or mouthwash

  • Rely on mild abrasives rather than peroxide

  • Good for maintaining results, rarely change shade on their own

  • Overusing abrasive pastes can roughen enamel, go easy


Bottom line: store bought products are best for maintenance, not major shade changes.


What’s New on the Horizon


  • PAP+, phthalimidoperoxycaproic acid. A peroxide free ingredient that may whiten with less sensitivity. Early data is encouraging.

  • AI guided LED systems. Sensors adjust light intensity to protect enamel.

  • Nano hydroxyapatite gels. Brighten and support re mineralization at the same time.

  • 3D printed trays. Faster turnaround and an even tighter fit.


These are promising, but new doesn’t automatically mean better. Let’s review the evidence together before you invest.


What Not to Do


  • Charcoal powders. Highly abrasive, can strip enamel and make teeth look dull over time.

  • Lemon juice or apple cider vinegar hacks. Acids erode enamel, which leads to sensitivity and more staining later.

  • Straight peroxide rinses. Can irritate soft tissue and cause prolonged discomfort.


Pro tip: if a whitening trick sounds like a household cleaning tip, keep it away from your teeth.


Managing Sensitivity


  1. Prep with desensitizing toothpaste that contains potassium nitrate or stannous fluoride for two weeks before whitening.

  2. Lower strength, shorter sessions if you tend to feel zingers.

  3. Avoid very hot or cold foods and drinks for 24 hours after each session.

  4. Ask about fluoride or nano hydroxyapatite varnishes in office to seal open tubules.

If discomfort persists, pause your treatment and call us.


Frequently Asked Questions


How long do whitening results last?Anywhere from six months to two years. Coffee, red wine, and smoking speed up re-staining. Regular cleanings and occasional touch ups help you maintain your shade.


Can I whiten if I have crowns or veneers?Yes, but porcelain and composite resin do not change color. We may whiten natural teeth first, then match any future restorations to the brighter shade.


Is whitening safe during pregnancy?Because research is limited, most dentists recommend waiting until after delivery.


I have sensitive teeth. Am I out of luck?Not at all. We can adjust gel strength, shorten wear times, and add professional desensitizers so you can brighten comfortably.


Teeth Whitening Checklist


  • Get a professional cleaning first so peroxide can contact clean enamel

  • Choose between in office whitening and custom trays. (We can help you decide).

  • Keep desensitizing toothpaste and a soft bristle brush on hand

  • For two weeks after whitening, limit black coffee, red wine, and berry smoothies, anything that would stain a white T shirt


Final Thoughts


Whitening should build confidence, not create a dental emergency. Whether you choose an in office session, custom trays, or a combination, professional guidance is the key to safe, predictable results.


Are you in Amherst, NY and thinking about whitening? Stop by our office. We’ll talk through your goals, check for any issues, and design a plan that protects your enamel and brightens your smile.


Call 716-839-2820 and let’s brighten your smile the right way!


bottom of page